Senators alarmed by ‘surge’ in violence against women; 5pc conviction rate termed ‘systemic failure’

The debate began after Balochistan Senator Naseema Ehsan raised the killing of Rubina Chandio for alleged ‘honour’ in Sindh’s Tando Masti.

“Rubina Chandio was killed in Sindh. She was given neither a funeral nor a shroud,” Ehsan said. She added that the woman was shot in front of a crowd, and the case surfaced after videos circulated on social media.

“The culprits involved in this brutal murder should also be hanged publicly,” she added.

Police suspect that Chandio was killed in a karo-kari case in Khairpur district.

‘Honour killings’ persist despite the 2016 anti-honour killing law that removed the option of pardoning by heirs. HRCP data says over 470 women were killed in the name of ‘honour’ in Pakistan in 2023.

Rehman called the situation “deeply distressing and unacceptable”. She said the country was witnessing a “dangerous surge in honour killings, rape, and other forms of gender-based violence”.

“The surge in these cases is deeply concerning. We cannot allow such brutality to become normalised,” she said.

She termed the 5pc conviction rate “an extremely alarming state of affairs”.

“When justice is delivered sporadically, it reflects a systemic failure,” she said, adding that the legislative framework existed, but “what is missing is implementation with resolve and consistency”.

Rehman also rejected the notion that such crimes were limited to remote areas or linked solely to poverty and illiteracy.

“These crimes also occur within influential households. Wealth, status, and education do not erase patriarchal thinking — often, they provide stronger networks of silence and protection,” she said.

She urged that cases be “continuously and rigorously taken up by the Senate Human Rights Committee”.

“True deterrence will only come when a few perpetrators are made unquestionable examples,” she said.

As presiding officer, she referred Chandio’s case to the rights committee for immediate scrutiny.

Federal Minister for Parliamentary Affairs Dr Tariq Fazal Chaudhry assured “full institutional support” to parliamentary committees working on crimes against women. He said the government would provide all necessary assistance whenever a committee seeks input from any ministry or department.

“Cooperation between the government and parliamentary committees is important for better governance and timely delivery of justice,” he said, adding that efforts to strengthen the justice system would continue.

Meanwhile, JUI-F Senator Maulana Atta ur Rehman told the House his party members were “unsafe” in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, citing the “targeted” killing of Maulana Muhammad Idrees.

He said the killers were “so expert” that only Idrees was killed while others in the vehicle were injured.

“Every week some heartbreaking incident happens in our area,” he said.

He also claimed the administration blocked the JUI-F’s protest over the killing.

“We said: you kill us and also don’t let us mourn. What answer do we give to our workers?” he asked.

The senator further said that the PTI had ruled the province for 13 years but has “lost the right to rule”.

“There is no law and order in our province. We are being killed and targeted daily,” he said, adding the provincial government tried to “shift blame to the federal government”.

He also questioned election transparency: “Are lists not prepared in advance?”

Taking aim at the centre, he said the federal government was “only busy brokering peace for America”.