Paul Adams: British-Israeli relations at lowest ebb in decades

To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser.This video can not be played

Watch: There is ethnic cleansing in areas of the West Bank, says Miliband

Israel's furious response to the British government's decision to ban trade with Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank testifies to just how important this moment is.

Britain took the brunt of Israel's anger, but the fact that 12 countries chose to move together clearly sharpened the sense of outrage.

Officials in London always knew that such a dramatic shift in policy towards Israel-Palestine was going to elicit a hostile response, but seemed taken aback by the speed and ferocity of Israel's reaction.

The closure of the UK's consulate in East Jerusalem, which serves the West Bank and deals directly with the Palestinian Authority in Ramallah, and the removal of British representatives from the International Gaza Support Centre, the body set up last year to co-ordinate stabilisation and relief efforts in the Gaza Strip, are very hostile moves.

They tell you that Israel is deeply troubled by Tuesday's action by the UK and 11 other countries, which include France, Spain and Canada.

Products manufactured in settlements may not represent a significant proportion of Israel's exports, but the political symbolism of singling these out for special treatment is powerful.

Image source, Ilia YEFIMOVICH / AFP via Getty ImagesImage caption, Three Israeli settlers - including an armed one - stand outside houses after the reopening of a settlement at Ganim in the Israeli-occupied West Bank in August

For decades, the British and other governments have regarded settlements in occupied Palestinian territory as illegal but stopped short of banning products grown or manufactured there.

Now, having announced that Britain agrees with the 2024 International Court of Justice ruling that the occupation as a whole - including Israel's military presence - is unlawful, Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband says the government's economic relationships must reflect that.

Hence the ban, not just on products but also on companies that provide construction, infrastructure or finance to settlements. The measures, which also include restrictions on arms sales that "materially contribute to the occupation", go further than many expected.

And it's not just the actions - it's the language of the foreign secretary's heartfelt, sometimes deeply personal statement that is so striking.

As a "proud British Jew... unwavering in my support for the state of Israel," Miliband spoke more directly and starkly than practically any of his predecessors.

That a British foreign secretary should say that "settler terrorism is rampant" and was responsible for the "ethnic cleansing" of Palestinians in parts of the West Bank, while the Israeli government "turned a blind eye to this" is truly remarkable.

Miliband calls this a "reset" in British policy. At times today, it felt like a radical rethink, and it leaves British-Israeli relations at their lowest ebb for decades.

Image source, EPA/ShutterstockImage caption, Six people, including three school pupils, have been killed in the West Bank village of al-Mughayyir this year, in a surge of settler-related violence against Palestinians

Yes, the heated, febrile atmosphere that invariably accompanies an impending Israeli election may have contributed to Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Saar's brutal response, but most Israelis will have shared his sense of outrage.

Many Israelis find the violent, messianic ideology of some settlers deeply problematic. Some see them as a national embarrassment.

But that's not the same as saying they agree that settlements, built on land captured during the 1967 Six Day War, are illegal.

Most would disagree violently with the former prime minister, Ehud Olmert, who last year accused his successor Benjamin Netanyahu of turning Israel into an international pariah.

But they can feel the walls of international opprobrium closing in - from protests at Eurovision or sporting events, to international arrest warrants being issued against their leaders and now to bans on settlement products - and that makes them anxious and defensive.

For the Palestinians, on the other hand, this feels like progress.

The Palestinian foreign ministry commended the countries adopting sanctions but called for "urgent, concrete measures" to stop Israel's "illegal settlement enterprise".

In London, the Palestinian ambassador Dr Husam Zomlot called the government's decision "a turning point in the UK-Palestine relationship".

Britain's "courageous steps", he said, would help pave the way for the independence of the State of Palestine on the 1967 borders, with East Jerusalem as its capital.

But Zomlot knows that the reality of Israel's 59-year occupation has not ended, or even substantially changed.

To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser.This video can not be played

Why is the UK against Israel's proposed West Bank E1 settlement?

The prospects for a viable Palestinian state remain vanishingly small, and there's little immediate sign that concerted action by 12 countries will reverse Israel's seemingly inexorable takeover of the West Bank.

Only the United States has that kind of influence, should it choose to wield it.

In 1991, President George HW Bush and his steely Secretary of State James Baker threatened to withhold $10bn (£7.4bn) in loan guarantees from the government of Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir, when the famously tough Shamir refused to promise that it wouldn't be used to finance settlement activity in the occupied territories.

But Donald Trump has so far shown no desire to curb Benjamin Netanyahu's settlement plans.

Some parts of Trump's MAGA movement have turned against Israel in recent years, but the US ambassador to Israel, Mike Huckabee, is a fervent Christian Zionist who shares Israel's view that the West Bank was promised to the Jews by God.

So Tuesday's action by the UK and its partners pits them not just against Israel but also against Israel's backer-in-chief in Washington.

Related topicsWest BankIsraelIsrael & the PalestiniansPalestinian territoriesMiddle EastMore on this story'Israeli settlers laid siege to our home': Inside a Palestinian village under weekly attack

In West Bank, date farmers weigh impact of UK sanctions on Israeli settlers

Palestinian parents fear for children's lives at school as settler attacks grow

PreviousNext0:56How Israel responded to UK sanctions on West Bank settlements. 00:00:56, play videoHow Israel responded to UK sanctions on West Bank settlements1:17'A&E failures ruined my son's life' 00:01:17, play video'A&E failures ruined my son's life'0:37UK to ban imports from Israeli settlements in West Bank. 00:00:37, play videoUK to ban imports from Israeli settlements in West Bank1:07Why do people get ill at Freshers? 00:01:07, play videoWhy do people get ill at Freshers?0:59Highest paid world leader to get $1m salary increase. 00:00:59, play videoHighest paid world leader to get $1m salary increase1:54Palestinian parents fear for children at school as settler attacks grow. 00:01:54, play videoPalestinian parents fear for children at school as settler attacks grow1:12Prince George arrives for first day at Eton. 00:01:12, play videoPrince George arrives for first day at Eton1:01Australians to be able to switch off social media algorithms. 00:01:01, play videoAustralians to be able to switch off social media algorithms2:28Residents fear drivers racing could kill someone. 00:02:28, play videoResidents fear drivers racing could kill someone1:11Will social media ban affect young food influencer's dream? 00:01:11, play videoWill social media ban affect young food influencer's dream?0:15When Mama Ru isn't fully sold on your concept. 00:00:15, play videoWhen Mama Ru isn't fully sold on your concept2:34New videos of man in 9/11 lawsuit reveal extremist links. 00:02:34, play videoNew videos of man in 9/11 lawsuit reveal extremist links0:52How Portsmouth residents feel about small boats protest. 00:00:52, play videoHow Portsmouth residents feel about small boats protest2:01Drug rape killer 'should never have been freed' says victim. 00:02:01, play videoDrug rape killer 'should never have been freed' says victim1:00British racing driver 'owes his life' to rival who rescued him from car fire. 00:01:00, play videoBritish racing driver 'owes his life' to rival who rescued him from car fire1:21Chemo hair loss doesn't define me. 00:01:21, play videoChemo hair loss doesn't define me0:15Video shows damaged Amazon cargo plane after crash kills five 00:00:15, play videoVideo shows damaged Amazon cargo plane after crash kills five 1:46US envoys in Kyiv a 'symbolic moment' 00:01:46, play videoUS envoys in Kyiv a 'symbolic moment'Top storiesUK announces sanctions on West Bank settlements prompting furious Israeli response

Paul Adams: British-Israeli relations at lowest ebb in decades

More flight delays expected after hundreds cancelled by air traffic control glitch

New mums 'left to get on with it' as C-section numbers in Wales hit record high

A&E did not get the basics right - my son's life was ruined at 32

British designer Paul Smith: 'Nobody cares how good you used to be in fashion' VideoBritish designer Paul Smith: 'Nobody cares how good you used to be in fashion'

Nigella praised as new Bake Off judge as latest contestants announced

Forget the Mediterranean diet, I'm eating only food from Shetland for a month

William, Harry and George: Royals' first days at Eton through the years. VideoWilliam, Harry and George: Royals' first days at Eton through the years

Primary teachers hired to teach Glasgow secondary pupils to read

Nurse said dementia patient 'didn't need birthday cake'

US Politics Unspun: Cut through the noise with Anthony Zurcher's newsletter

Your first look at the new series of the Belfast-based police drama

Lord Sugar: From car aerials to business empire

Follow the life-saving decisions of dedicated A&E teams

Should rivers have legal rights?

More flight delays expected after hundreds cancelled by air traffic control glitch

Glastonbury confirms ticket sale dates - and highest ever price

RNLI volunteers facing 'unacceptable' abuse, chief says

UK announces sanctions on West Bank settlements prompting furious Israeli response

Trump shares misleading video of King and fainting worker

British widow faces deportation from Sweden after 22 years

Very hot drinks may damage the food pipe and increase cancer risk

'Constantly on my mind' - 9/11 agony goes on for bereaved, 25 years on

Paul Adams: British-Israeli relations at lowest ebb in decades

I was fired from The Voice - I didn't want to leave, says Sir Tom Jones